Creating a Safe Space for Children in the West Bank: A Reflection on Teaching in Nablus

By: Emily Zanieski 12/2/23

Peer Reviewed by REAL Members


“Miss Emily…Miss Emily,” I heard as I started my journey into Nablus’ Old City after spending my day creating lesson plans for my upcoming week of English classes. From the hill adjacent to my path came two 7-year-olds running down to greet me with hugs and high-fives before introducing me to their family who worked in a local shop across the street. Two weeks later, I would run into the same children. This time, when taking me to their family, I was met with tea and we exchanged stories about our lives, each using each other’s native language. This was just one of the many experiences I had while teaching in Palestine this past summer.

Prior to arriving in Palestine, I had no experience teaching children, making lesson plans, working with co-teachers, or leading a classroom. What I did have was a strong passion for making education more equitable in emergency contexts and an open heart. Having just finished my first year at George Washington University, I was eager to have the opportunity to take what I had learned about working in education in emergency situations and apply it in my work as a teacher. That being said…I was extremely nervous. While I had talked about the importance of social emotional learning (SEL) for refugees during my Education in Emergencies course in the spring, I was unsure if I was the right person for this job. Although I speak Arabic and have been engaged with Middle Eastern studies since my undergraduate career, I also knew I was coming to Nablus as a white American who did not have any experience with displacement or conflict. As a firm believer of participatory processes in education, I knew that although I would be teaching students my native language, I would be learning from them, my other teachers, and locals what Palestinians in Nablus experience daily. Luckily, at Tomorrow’s Youth Organization (TYO), I worked alongside local Nablusi teachers, learning what SEL meant for their students both inside and outside the classroom. 

TYO is an American non-profit organization based in Nablus that supports refugees and marginalized communities through holistic approaches to education, focusing not only on academic goals but addressing the physical, social, and emotional needs of their students. By hiring local staff, TYO has successfully fostered relationships, built rapport and gained credibility across Nablus as a leader in education. During the summer, TYO runs two summer camps focused on developing students’ English-language abilities and SEL skills. To achieve their goals in developing students’ English, TYO brings native English speakers from around the world to lead daily English lessons, among other activities. In implementing SEL in the classroom, TYO utilizes the World Bank’s Step-by-Step toolkit to promote skills in self-awareness, self-regulation, social awareness, positive communication, determination, and responsible decision making. Prior to the first summer camp, TYO’s teachers participated in a localization training so they could adjust the World Bank’s toolkit to fit the needs of students in their classrooms. Going through my program orientation and meeting weekly with my 2nd grade teacher helped me get a better understanding of what locals believe should be taught, and we worked together to make lesson plans that would promote our educational goals while ensuring students had fun.

Believing that education for children must go beyond academic solutions, I worked to incorporate daily SEL goals into my lessons. One of my students’ favorite lessons was the day we focused on self-awareness and love through the creation of a “I love myself” mirror. At the beginning of the lesson, we practiced the body parts vocabulary through dancing along to “head, shoulders, knees, and toes”. Afterwards, we worked on crafting a mirror so students could see themselves and begin identifying things they liked about themselves. On the handle of the mirror, students were encouraged to write their names and practice writing the phrase “I love me” in order to promote the idea of self-love and self-esteem. As students came up to me, showed me their mirror, and pointed to themselves while saying “I love me,” I couldn’t help myself from smiling and making sure that they knew they were loved by their family, friends, and teachers as well.

One of my students making his “I Love Myself mirror”

Besides seeing firsthand the positive impact SEL can have for refugee students, the biggest takeaway from my time in Palestine, both in planning my lessons and in teaching, was learning how to be flexible.

Throughout the West Bank and Gaza, prolonged school closures due to the COVID-19 pandemic, compounded with “widespread security constraints and teachers’ strikes” (UNICEF, 2023) has resulted in Palestinian students receiving disrupted education, and in many cases, no education at all. For many of my 7 and 8-year-olds, they had not been in a classroom for three years. Because of this, my expectations on what I believed students ‘should’ know coming into class drastically changed in the first 30 minutes of my first class. In my first lesson, this meant changing my lesson in the middle of class, adjusting to have students introduce themselves and their favorite color instead of their favorite activity. By the end of my summer, this meant spending multiple days on 1 topic and introducing it in new ways to test if students understood the concepts I was teaching. 

I also had to learn how to be flexible purely because of the situation in Nablus. City-wide closures and randomly occurring raids in refugee camps meant that at best, some students were not in class, but oftentimes meant that students were not coming in for the day. The clearest example of this was when Israeli airstrikes and ground operations in Jenin–a city roughly one hour away from Nablus–prevented students from coming to TYO for an entire week due to safety concerns. The 14 days of summer camp students were promised turned into 9. Disruption to children’s education must inspire us to seek out new and innovative ways to increase educational opportunities for students affected by crisis and conflict.

My summer in Nablus was truly an unforgettable experience. It is one thing to sit in Washington DC and talk about refugee education; it’s another thing to be in the classroom teaching students who have experienced life as a refugee. For people looking to work in the field of international education, especially for those interested in education in emergencies, I would encourage seeking out opportunities that allow you to learn from local communities. I believe that by working alongside and listening to the locals about the support they need from the international community, I have become a better advocate for education, not only in Palestine, but across the world.

Early Childhood Education for Refugees in the United States

By: Isabelle Hoagland

Peer-reviewed by REAL members

Introduction

Early Childhood Education (ECE) is an essential component of a child’s development during critical years of its life, yet it is often inaccessible for refugee families in the United States Despite ample evidence in favor of creating widespread access to high-quality ECE, the U.S. does not have universal childcare or ECE programs. The federal Head Start program does help provide access to ECE for underserved populations, yet many barriers often prevent refugee families from accessing the Head Start program. In this blog post, I will 1) establish the importance of ECE, 2) reflect on my interview with the executive director of the Community Action Agency of Somerville, MA, David Gibbs, who oversees the city’s Head Start program; and 3) provide recommendations to help ensure access to ECE for refugees in the U.S.

Early Childhood Development 

Early Childhood Development (ECD) encompasses a child’s physical, cognitive, linguistic, and social emotional development from a prenatal stage through primary school (UNICEF, 2017). Ninety percent of brain development occurs before the age of five, according to the National Child Traumatic Stress Network (2010), providing a small window of opportunity in a child’s early years of life to maximize the scope of the brain’s cognitive and language abilities, social skills, and socioemotional development (UNICEF, 2017). Early education is an essential component of healthy child development (Nurturing Care, 2020). 

Research on high-quality ECE establishes both short- and long-term advantages (Morland et al., 2016; Karoly et al., 2005). Children who have participated in ECE are less likely to be unemployed or incarcerated later in life, are more likely to graduate from high school, and on average earn higher salaries than those who do not (Meloy et al., 2019). Longitudinal research of preschool programs has found up to $17 returned in social benefits for every dollar invested (Meloy et al., 2019). Furthermore, according to Meloy et al. (2019), high-quality ECE helps close gaps in educational and life outcomes between lower- and upper-income families. ECE has been shown to increase children’s socioemotional skills and school readiness (Arapa et al., 2021; Barnett, 1992), and provide a healing environment for those who have been exposed to trauma (The National Scientific Council on the Developing Child 2005/2014). For children who have experienced trauma or adverse childhood experiences, ECE programs have the potential to offer a nurturing and healing environment. 

Head Start Programs

The U.S. does not have universal childcare or ECE programs. Instead, it is the responsibility of individual states and localities to decide what kind of programs to provide, if any (Park, 2018). Some states offer free preschool and ECE for low-income families, but these provisions are ad hoc. However, in 1964, President Johnson created the federally-funded Head Start program with the goal of providing a comprehensive ECD program that would serve low-income and underprivileged communities (Department of Health and Human Services, 2021). Refugees in the U.S. are eligible to enroll in these programs; however, many barriers exist to accessing them. A lack of qualified, bilingual, and culturally competent preschool teachers, ECE staff, and providers make the programs largely inaccessible to refugee families (Park, 2018). Research shows that families with limited proficiency in English or formal education are less likely to enroll their children in ECEC programs due to enrollment barriers (Morland et al., 2016). Beyond Head Start programs, little to no infrastructure exists in the U.S. for refugee children ECE (Park, 2018). This speaks to the broader issue of the lack of universal ECE programs in the country. 

I had the chance to speak with David Gibbs, who oversees the Head Start program in Sommerville, MA. In our conversation, Gibbs explained to me that Head Start is a center-based preschool program that also provides holistic wraparound services for the children and their families. Enrollment in Head Start is typically competitive due to high demand and few slots available. To be eligible for Head Start, a family’s income must not exceed 125 percent of the federal poverty line. However, a child may be otherwise qualified by virtue of 1) having a learning disability, 2) being involved with local child abuse or neglect agency, 3) if they are currently homeless, or 4) if they are a refugee.  All children enrolled in a Head Start program receive health supervision, vaccinations, regular checkups, access to mental health and disability specialists, and nutrition specialists. Additionally, any family member may receive referrals to mental and primary health services. 

An opportunity exists for the Office of Refugee Resettlement (ORR) to establish a collaboration with the Office of Head Start (OHS). This collaboration could work to ensure that refugee families are aware of local ECE programs available to them and could aid in navigating the enrollment process, addressing one of the key barriers to access that refugee families face. There is currently very little communication between refugee services, which are led by the government, and ECE services, which are run by individual states and localities (Park, 2018). According to Morland et al. (2016), “Head Start is well positioned to work with resettlement programs to help ease the transition of refugee families to their new communities, provide centralized access to key comprehensive services, and improve overall school readiness for children of refugee families” (p. 2). However, such collaboration does not exist in most places in the country, likely due to a silo effect within organizations.

Recommendations

Research has demonstrated that collaboration between federal, state, and local agencies is beneficial in creating access to ECE for refugee children (Morland et al., 2016). As such, I recommend the following to help ensure access to Head Start programs for refugee children:

  1. ORR should establish a firm collaboration with OHS. Partnerships between ORR and OHS, whose services typically do not interact (Morland et al., 2016), would help ensure that all refugee families with young children are aware of Head Start programs available to them and ensure equitable access, while also signaling the importance of ECE. 
  2. Refugee resettlement agencies should prioritize connecting families with young children to local Head Start programs. A collaboration between resettlement agencies and local Head Start programs would create an avenue to support refugee access to and enrollment in ECE. Refugee families with young children would greatly benefit from Head Start’s wraparound services after they stop receiving support from the resettlement office. 

References

Arapa, B., Sánchez, E., Hurtado-Mazeyra, A., & Sánchez, A. (2021). The relationship between access to pre-school education and the development of social-emotional competencies: Longitudinal evidence from Peru. International Journal of Educational Development, 87, 102482. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijedudev.2021.102482

Barnett, W. S. (1992). Benefits of Compensatory Preschool Education. The Journal of Human Resources, 27(2), 279–312. https://doi.org/10.2307/145736

Bouchane, Kollen, Molly Curtiss, and Bethany Ellis. 2016. Safe Spaces: The Urgent Need for Early Childhood Development in Emergencies and Disasters. London: Theirworld. https://theirworld.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/10/Safespaces_report.pdf

Department of Health and Human Services. (2021). Head Start History. https://www.acf.hhs.gov/ohs/about/history-head-start

Karoly, L. A., Kilburn, M. R., & Cannon, J. S. (2005). Early childhood interventions: Proven results, future promise. Rand.

Meloy, B., Gardner, M., & Darling-Hammond, L. (2019). Untangling the Evidence on Preschool Effectiveness: Insights for Policymakers. Learning Policy Institute. https://learningpolicyinstitute.org/product/untangling-evidence-preschool-effectiveness-report

Morland, L., Ives, N., McNeely, C., & Allen, C. (2016). Providing a Head Start: Improving Access to Early Childhood Education for Refugees. 37.

Moving Minds Alliance. (2020). Analysis-of-international-aid-levels-for-early-childhood-services-in-crisis-contexts.pdf. https://movingmindsalliance.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/12/analysis-of-international-aid-levels-for-early-childhood-services-in-crisis-contexts.pdf

Park, M. (2018). Responding to the ECEC Needs of Children of Refugees and Asylum Seekers in Europe and North America. 70.

Ponguta, L. A., Aragón, C. A., Varela, L. R., Moore, K., Hein, S., & Cerezo, A. (2020). Sector‐wide analysis of early childhood development and education in emergencies in Colombia and considerations to strengthen systems globally. New Directions for Child and Adolescent Development, 2020(172), 103–123. https://doi.org/10.1002/cad.20367

Refugee Resettlement and Child Care Partnerships: Partnering to Increase Refugee Families’ Access to High-Quality Child Care. (2014). https://www.acf.hhs.gov/occ/policy-guidance/refugee-resettlement-and-child-care-partnerships-partnering-increase-refugee

Refugees, U. N. H. C. for. (n.d.). UNHCR Education Report 2021: “Staying the course” – The challenges facing refugee education. UNHCR. Retrieved March 27, 2022, from https://www.unhcr.org/publications/education/612f85d64/unhcr-education-report-2021-staying-course-challenges-facing-refugee-education.html

Statman-Weil, K. (2015). Creating Trauma- Sensitive Classrooms. 8.

Taylor, S., & Sidhu, R. K. (2012). Supporting refugee students in schools: What constitutes inclusive education? International Journal of Inclusive Education, 16(1), 39–56. https://doi.org/10.1080/13603110903560085

The National Scientific Council on the Developing Child. (2005). Stress Disrupts the Architecture of the Developing Brain. 12.

UNICEF-Programme- Guidance-for-Early-Childhood-Development-2017.pdf. (2017). UNICEF.

United Nations Association of the National Capital Area. (2021). Climate Displacement.pdf. Google Docs. https://drive.google.com/file/d/1Lpmw8zjzSqDVGWOtQFpmOBeXRolruiJT/view?usp=embed_facebook

US Department of State. (2022). Refugee Admissions. United States Department of State. https://www.state.gov/refugee-admissions/

What is Nurturing Care? (2020, November 19). https://nurturing-care.org/what-is-nurturing-care/