Institute for International Economic Policy (IIEP)

At the Elliott School of International Affairs

A tale of two wage subsidies: The American and Australian fiscal responses to COVID-19

August 4, 2020 2020 Steven Hamilton Working Papers

July 2020

Steven Hamilton (George Washington University)

IIEP working paper 2020-12

Abstract: Australia suppressed the virus with swift and strong public health measures including stringent border controls. As of July 2020, the virus continues to spread uncontrolled across the US, resulting in the most recorded cases and deaths of any country. Both countries instituted widespread lock-downs and similarly generous fiscal support, yet Australia has experienced a far milder recession, highlighting the critical role of public health measures in protecting the economy. The role of broad cash stimulus necessarily has been more limited than in an ordinary recession, justifying the use of wage subsidies that encourage businesses to retain workers. The Australian wage subsidy, delivered via the tax authority, was better targeted, more generous, more accessible, but slower to deliver liquidity than the American wage subsidy delivered via private banks. The experience highlights the critical need for significant investments in IRS infrastructure to better prepare for future crises.

 

JEL Codes:

Key Words: 

Steven Hamilton

Women at Work in the Pre-Civil War United States: An Analysis of Unreported Family Workers

A Paradox of Morality: Using Games to Understand Group Moral Responsibility

Search
Events
  • Research
    • International Trade
    • International Finance
    • International Development
    • International Economic Policy
    • Publications
      • Working Papers
        • Working Papers – 2018
        • Working Papers – 2017
        • Working Papers – 2016
        • Working Papers – 2015
        • Working Papers – 2014
        • Working Papers – 2013
        • Working Papers – Climate Adaptation
        • Working Papers – Development Economics
        • Working Papers – Global Governance
        • Working Papers – International Finance
        • Working Papers – International Trade
        • Working Papers – Ultra Poverty
        • Working Papers – U.S.-China
        • Working Papers – 2012
        • Working Papers – 2011
        • Working Papers – 2010
        • Working Papers – 2009
        • Working Papers – 2008
        • Working Papers – Adam Ziegfeld
        • Working Papers – Ajay Chhibber
        • Working Papers – Al Wood
        • Working Papers – Ana Fostel
        • Working Papers – Arun Malik
        • Working Papers – Bryan Stuart
        • Working Papers – Carmel Chiswick
        • Working Papers – Chao Wei
        • Working Papers – Chrysanthi Hatzimasoura
        • Working Papers – Danny M. Leipziger
        • Working Papers – David Szakonyi
        • Working Papers – Frederick L. Joutz
        • Working Papers – Gabriela Aparicio
        • Working Papers – Graciela Laura Kaminsky
        • Working Papers – Herman Stekler
        • Working Papers – James Foster
        • Working Papers – Jay Shambaugh
        • Working Papers – Joseph Pelzman
        • Working Papers – Llewelyn Hughes
        • Working Papers – Maggie Chen
        • Working Papers – Michael Bradley
        • Working Papers – Michael O. Moore
        • Working Papers – Nora Lustig
        • Working Papers – Olga Timoshenko
        • Working Papers – Paul Carrillo
        • Working Papers – Robert Weiner
        • Working Papers – Sarah Baird
        • Working Papers – Shahe Emran
        • Working Papers – Stephen B. Kaplan
        • Working Papers – Stephen C. Smith
        • Working Papers – Steve Charnovitz
        • Working Papers – Steve Suranovic
        • Working Papers – Sumit Joshi
        • Working Papers – Susan Aaronson
        • Working Papers – Susan Sell
        • Working Papers – Tomas Williams
        • Working Papers – Tony Castleman
        • Working Papers – Yao Pan
        • Working Papers – Ram Fishman
        • Working Papers – Remi Jedwab
        • Working Papers – Marcus D. King
        • Working Papers – Tara Sinclair
        • Working Papers – Anthony Yezer
        • Working Papers
        • 2021
        • 2019
        • Working Papers – Barry Chiswick
        • Working Papers – Steven Hamilton
        • Working Papers – Elira Kuka
        • Working Papers – Irene R. Foster
        • 2020
  • Signature Initiatives
    • Climate Change and Sustainable Cities
    • Economics of Poverty and Inequality
    • U.S.-China Economic Relations
    • Global Economic Governance
  • Academics
    • Executive Education
    • Economic Review Sessions
      • Online Economic Principles Programs
      • Online Economics Review Programs
      • Elliott School Online Economics Assessment
      • Registration and Payment
    • Masters Programs
    • Undergraduate Courses
    • Doctoral Programs
  • Blog
  • ‏‏‎ ‎
  • People
    • Our Affiliated Faculty
      • Barry Chiswick
        • Bibliographies
    • Our Visiting Scholars
      • Former Visiting Scholars
    • Our Staff
      • Former Staff (2021-2022)
      • Former Staff (2022-2023)
    • Executive Circle
    • Leadership
  • News
    • Upcoming Events
    • Past Events
      • Past Events – Seminar
      • Past Events – Forum
      • Past Events – Research Conference
      • Past Events – Adaptation to Climate Change
      • Past Events – Development Economics and Poverty Alleviation
      • Past Events – Economics of Ultra-Poverty
      • Past Events – Global Economic Governance
        • Annual Washington Area Labor Economics Symposium (WALES)
      • Past Events – International Finance
      • Past Events – International Trade
      • Past Events – U.S.-China Economic Relations
      • #7011 (no title)
  • Stephen C. Smith
    • Brief Biography
    • Books
    • Research Papers
    • Teaching and Courses
    • Professional Affiliations
  • Articles
  • Books
  • Commentary and Op-Eds
  • Annual Washington Area Development Economics Symposium (WADES)
  • Ajay Chhibber
    • Ajay Chhibber – Commentary
    • Ajay Chhibber – Biography
  • Jay C. Shambaugh
    • Biography
    • Books
    • Research
    • Teaching
    • Data
  • Sarah Baird, Ph.D., M.S.
    • Biography
    • Publications
    • Courses
    • Professional Affiliations
  • Steve Suranovic
    • Books
    • Working Papers
    • Courses
  • James E. Foster
    • Current Research
    • Selected Publications
    • Courses
    • News
  • Joseph Pelzman
    • Books
    • Working Papers
    • Journal Articles
    • Funded Grant and Contract Studies
    • Courses
    • Professional Conferences
  • Tony Castleman
    • Publications
    • Working Papers
    • Research in Progress
  • Elliott School Economics Assessment FAQs
  • 9th Washington Area International Trade Symposium (WAITS) Conference
  • Intermediate Theory Programs
  • Sunil Sharma
  • China’s Economic Development and U.S.-China Economic Relations
  • ANNUAL
  • Annual Washington Area International Trade Symposium (WAITS) Conference
  • Annual Washington Area Labor Economics Symposium (WALES)
  • Annual Urbanization and Poverty Reduction Research Conference
  • Newsletter Archives
  • DRAFT: Past Events
  • Annual Washington Area Development Economics Symposium (WADES)
  • Research Assistants
  • research
  • Meet Our Staff
  • Digital Communication & Social Media Staff
  • Events & Operations Staff
  • Technical Staff
  • #7944 (no title)
  • Trevor Jackson – Commentary
  • Annual Conferences
  • Condemning systemic racism: A message from IIEP Director James Foster
  • Former Staff
  • Andrew Brown MA ’07, CFA
  • Events
    • International Trade
  • Michael Smart BA ’92
  • Former Staff (2020-2021)
  • James Quigley BA ’82
  • Victor Vilaplana MA ’70
  • Frank Chi-Hong Wong, BA ’79
  • Deborah Lehr MA ’89
  • Carolina Costa MA ’07
  • Rethinking Capitalism & Democracy
  • Nizar Qallab MA ’05
  • Envisioning India and India-US Economic Relations
  • Envisioning India
  • Envisioning India and India-US Economic Relations
  • Dan Strammiello BA ’66
  • Sean Connell MA ’06
  • Sean Connell MA ’06
  • Lubna Qunash MBA ’06, MA ’06
  • Carl Richardson MA ’99
  • Erik Kiefel MA ’94
  • Michael Batlogg MA ’08, MBA ’08
  • Lisa Schroeter BA ’92
  • Facing Inequality
  • 10th Washington Area International Trade Symposium (WAITS) Conference
  • Carmel Chiswick
    • Education and Employment History
    • Nonacademic Activities in Jewish Studies
    • Research Publications: Labor and Demography
    • Economics of Religion: Academic Activities in Jewish Studies
    • Economic Development
    • Research on Thailand
    • Statistics, Data, and Measurement
    • Other
    • Public Presentations
  • Maxmillian Angerholzer III
  • Kevin Conboy MS, MBA, BBA
  • Moses Kansanga
    • Selected Publications
  • Climate
  • 3rd Annual Washington Area Labor Economics Symposium (WALES)
  • Indira Iyer
  • Blogs
  • Anthony Yu, BA ’04, MA
  • Patrick Hyland BA ’96 MA ’03
  • Robert Weiner
    • Videos
  • #21288 (no title)
  • Our Staff
  • Sarah Hirsch, BA ‘10
  • 15th Annual Conference on China’s Economic Development and U.S.-China Relations
  • Test
  • About Us
  • Michael Rendina BA ’02 MA ’05 GWU
  • Jim Wodarski, BA ’89
  • Sustainable Economic Growth
  • Ray Brimble MA ’76
  • Jonathan Aiken, MBA ’07, MA ’07
  • Basem Malhas, GWSB ’96
  • James Berger CCAS ’89; ESIA P’25; GWSB P’26
  • Karl Wachter, ESIA ’92
  • Anthony Ragozino P’25
  • Steven Mayo MA-MBA ‘10
  • Our History
  • GW India
  • GW China
  • Walter Vester
Proudly powered by WordPress | Theme: Doo by ThemeVS.
The George Washington University, Washington, DC
  • Campus Advisories
  • EO/Nondiscrimination Policy
  • Website Privacy Notice
  • Contact GW
  • Accessibility
  • Terms of Use
  • Copyright
  • Report a barrier to accessibility.
Viewing Message: 1 of 1.
Notice

This site uses cookies to offer you a better browsing experience. Visit GW’s Website Privacy Notice to learn more about how GW uses cookies.