I regularly read Ron Charles's Washington Post Friday Book Club newsletter, always chock full of interesting topics and writers I haven't yet explored. This Friday he included a quote from controversial (accused of plagiarism) Turkish author and activist Elif Shafak
“... we are living in a world in which there is way too much information, but little knowledge and even less wisdom.… As we scroll up and down, more out of habit than out of anything else, we have no time to process what we see. No time to absorb or reflect or feel. Hyper-information gives us the illusion of knowledge. For true knowledge to be attained we need to slow down. We need cultural spaces, literary festivals, an open and honest intellectual exchange.”
This blog is my attempt to machete a trail through all the various forms of information and provide some bridge to knowledge and wisdom by providing links to reliable original sources. Speaking of which, we are now in the midst of ID Week, probably the most prestigious annual infectious diseases research conference, and many of my regular ID feeds are filled with reports of presentations. However, I virtually never include these reports in this blog, because there is no way via these abstracts to look for potential flaws or limitations in the research, and it is well known that research meeting presentation findings often change dramatically by the time they are published in a peer-reviewed journal, if they are ever published at all.
WRIS
Still pretty quiet on the Winter Respiratory Infection Season, with some hints of beginnings of influenza and RSV increasing. Perhaps the only item of interest is an increase in Mycoplasma pneumoniae activity, probably just a regular wave that tends to happen with this pathogen, though delayed somewhat due to pandemic mitigation strategies. It's not a reportable disease, so it's hard to find good data on incidence over time. As most providers know, this is a self-limited illness that produces generally mild illness (so-called walking pneumonia) and usually not worth diagnosing or treating. Because of its self-limited nature, it's been difficult to demonstrate any benefit of antibiotic treatment compared to placebo, and I doubt we'll see any placebo-controlled randomized trials in the near future.
Compared to last winter, CDC is predicting a 54% chance of a similar combined peak of respiratory illnesses, with a 28% chance of a lower peak and 18% chance of a higher peak.
Infectious Complications of Hurricanes
These tend to get less coverage than do the more obvious loss of life and property destruction occurring immediately during a natural disaster, but the Florida Department of Health is now reporting on a surge in cases of necrotizing fasciitis due to Vibrio vulnificus, a known salt and brackish water pathogen. Here are the numbers:
As a reminder, individuals with immunodeficiencies, but also particularly including chronic liver or renal disease, are at high risk for V. vulnificus complications. CDC has a good summary.
Conjunctivitis
Researchers in Colorado looked at about 200 children with acute conjunctivitis compared to a similar number of children who were either healthy or had URI without conjunctival involvement. Long story short, they found no benefit of ophthalmic ointment treatment, but did see a 20% incidence of antibiotic side effects. The study itself didn't replicate real-world situations for providers; for example, they employed broad spectrum PCR testing looking for a large number of bacteria and viruses. The study doesn't give us much direction for practical approaches to this problem but does serve as a reminder to limit topical and other antibiotic use in acute conjunctivitis in children,
Outpatient Infant Botulism?
I would never have thought of this, I've only been called for hospitalized children with infant botulism. It turns out, though, that there are rare instances of milder disease managed as outpatients. A team reviewing the California Department of Public Health data from 1976 - 2021 found 17 of 4372 cases (0.4%) were outpatients. (Note that California cases account for about 1/3 of all US infant botulism cases.) Here's the breakdown of clinical findings.
The median age at onset of symptoms was 20 weeks, with a range of 6 - 55 weeks. Only 1 child had been exposed to honey.
Polio Updates
The second round of novel oral polio type 2 vaccinations have begun in Gaza, though I haven't heard much about ceasefires to help facilitate this critical second round. Meanwhile, this week the Global Polio Elimination Initiative had to bow to reality and revise plans and timeline for polio elimination worldwide. Now, the end of 2027 is the target for elimination of wild poliovirus infections, with end of 2029 for elimination of type 2 vaccine-derived polio. This will take significantly more funding, and the greater the risk of prolonged or new wars the less likely these targets will be achieved.
The DIKW Pyramid
I'm accustomed to using the evidence-based medicine pyramid for hierarchies of study design in medicine, but in researching Dr. Shafak's quote about wisdom I happened onto the Data, Information, Knowledge, and Wisdom pyramid. It doesn't appear to incorporate anything about the role of false or misleading data, so I'm not sure if it is a helpful model in our era. As artificial intelligence becomes more entrenched (it's impossible to remove that view from Google Chrome!), we need to be even more vigilant about our data sources.
HAL 9000 looks a lot like my doorbell. Yikes!