You know things are slow in my world if I'm mentioning pestes des petits ruminants, aka goat plague, but it has been in the news lately and does have relevance to us. Spoiler alert, you don't need to break out the masks and gloves, the virus causing this disease has never been reported to infect humans.
We're talking primarily about covid and avian flu at the moment. Covid wastewater levels may be starting to level off, except in the southern US.
The clinical respiratory illness map is a beautiful sea of green (with a bit of light green in Alaska). I'm only showing this to remember fondly come next winter.
Not a lot to report on the avian flu front, with a continued sprinkling of new mild human illness in poultry/dairy workers and new outbreaks in flocks and herds. I was interested to see that CDC is making a $5 million investment to provide seasonal flu vaccine to at risk workers. Of course we want everyone eligible to vaccinate themselves against seasonal influenza, but the ulterior motive here is to lessen the chance that a human will be simultaneously infected with a seasonal flu strain along with the influenza A H5N1 avian strain. Such a situation could increase the likelihood of reassortment of the 2 strains to create a new virus that could cause more problems for us. This scenario is still a rare probability but worth preventive measures.
PPRV and Cousins
The virus that causes PPR is a morbillivirus, which should sound familiar to healthcare providers because that is the same genus as measles virus. You can learn more than you want to know about PPR from the article from which the figure below was lifted.
Morbilliviruses in general have the theoretical ability to be eradicated. In fact, one animal morbillivirus, rinderpest virus, already has been eradicated. PPR has been targeted for eradication by 2030, but a recent outbreak in Greece now threatens that with spread from Africa and the Middle East to the European Union. Infection has a very high fatality rate in goats, sheep, camels, and other ruminants that provide livelihoods to many. So, although PPRV doesn't infect humans, runinant infection is a major threat to livelihoods of those in these countries who depend on these animal industries. The World Organisation for Animal Health nicely summarizes eradication tools in place, let's hope the Greek outbreak doesn't set eradication plans back too far. (Also, if you're looking for a rabbit (only slight pun here) hole to fall down, check out WOAH's list of 207 animal diseases.)
The real reason I mention PPR is to draw attention to somewhat misleading measles pronouncements in the lay press this past week. NBC, among virtually every national news agency I could find, highlighted the CDC announcement that US measles cases have tripled this year compared to all of 2023. That's true but also misleading. I understand this helps get the message out that measles vaccination rates are low in many segments of society, but by using this relative increase in cases as a headline it overlooks the fact that the actual number of cases is still low, thank goodness. To its credit, the NBC link above did go on to give these details, but in our sound bite world that clarification is easily lost. Here's a bit more perspective from CDC.
From the same website, you can see how graphs can be used to stress a particular point - the perspective below would make us think everything is great. Just by expanding the date range, we can hardly see anything going on this year.
CDC regularly updates assessments of measles outbreak risk in the US. Currently they predict the most likely number of cases for 2024 will total 300, with a 4% risk of >1000 cases. Keep that in mind over the next 5 months.
Don't get me wrong, I'm all for increasing measles vaccination rates; however, I don't want to do this without presenting an accurate view of the data. I'd make a terrible salesperson or politician.
The 33rd edition of the American Academy of Pediatrics' 2024-2027 Report of the Committee on Infectious Diseases, aka Red Book, arrived online (and on my doorstep) recently. This latest edition adds about 100 pages to the 32nd edition, even as many sections were combined or shortened. More than annual spring cleaning, this is a renewal effort for me that has become an enjoyable triennial task for me. Although the early pages provide a brief summary of changes (total 222) from the previous edition, I operationalize this by having the new Red Book at my side always, looking up every clinical situation I encounter in reading or in patient care. Not surprisingly, even after doing this for maybe the next year, I still won't remember everything, but I'll know when and where to look. Remember also that the Red Book advice is in many instances a set of consensus opinions that are subject to author bias, even with extensive review and editing. Nothing is etched in stone, and individual patient circumstances may require deviation from general recommendations.
In the meantime, let's look at what's been going on in pediatric infectious diseases recently; this isn't in the Red Book.
A New Look CDC Website
Our friends at CDC announced a new look to their website with a focus on reducing clutter and making access easier. After my first series of run-throughs, I think they are well on their way to that goal. It's worth your while to view their 2-minute YouTube video describing the changes.
Bird Flu News
Still no reason to increase fears of the next human pandemic, but plenty going on. The US Department of Agriculture (they should talk to their CDC colleagues about reducing website clutter and improving navigation!) updated beef safety with some new studies. First, USDA tested ground beef samples from stores in states known to have influenza A H5N1 present in cattle; all were negative by PCR, although they don't mention how many samples were tested. Second, they performed studies on cooking ground beef spiked with Highly Pathogenic Avian Influenza "surrogate" virus (they don't specify details or numbers). Cooking the burgers to medium (145 F) or well done (160 F) eliminated all live virus. Rare (120 F) cooking "substantially inactivated" the virus, whatever that means. I'm looking forward to results of another ongoing study of PCR testing of muscle samples from cows who were culled due to "systemic pathologies" which should go a long way in helping understand if there is any reasonable risk of transmission of H5N1 in raw beef.
Meanwhile, in the latest update there have been no new state detections in domestic livestock since April 24. Bird infections remain a major problem as judged from USDA's main avian influenza website.
FDA provided a little more detailed information than did USDA. They found no viable virus in 297 pasteurized dairy products tested and confirmed by egg inoculation studies which should be highly sensitive.
Things are improving, but more proactive testing, especially of asymptomatic wild and domestic animals and high-risk humans such as poultry and dairy workers, is needed to stay ahead of any epidemic trends.
MMWR Trifecta
I'm not a big horse-racing fan, though I did watch the Preakness this weekend. This week's (May 16) MMWR hit a trifecta for me in that 3 topics are worth mentioning, so here's a quick look.
Measles: We have a detailed report of the outbreak associated with the migrant shelter in Chicago, spread over February through April 2024. Here's the quick overview:
The key take-home points: 1) Most of the 57 cases occurred in unvaccinated individuals; 2) active case-finding and a mass vaccination campaign (882 residents were vaccinated) likely averted a larger disaster.
I wish we had similar reporting from the Florida public school outbreak, apparently managed very differently but we know nothing about what was done. I can still find only a March 8 update that sounds mostly like a political statement.
Clade I Mpox: This clade I outbreak continues in the Democratic Republic of Congo and, compared to the clade II strain that caused the global outbreak in 2022, this clade I seems more virulent, with higher morbidity and mortality than seen with clade II (this was known prior to this outbreak). Again, here's the big picture:
While the numbers appear to be trending downward in the latter dates on this graph, this could be due to delays in reporting.
Age distributions are alarming for pediatric healthcare providers though clearly are influenced by social factors present in the DRC and might not apply to any US cases if we do see global spread.
The Jynneos mpox vaccine is effective against both clades, and high-risk individuals in the US should be vaccinated. The newly revamped CDC mpox site is a good example of how they've improved the look and ease of navigation. Providers should access this again to be sure they have offered vaccine to those at risk.
Polio: This was an update on progress towards polio eradication and is a good news/bad news report. The good news is that wild-type polio infections appear to be decreasing over the period January 2022 to December 2023. Wild type polioviruses types 2 and 3 (WPV2 and WPV3) have been eradicated, and only WPV1 continues to circulate but just in Afghanistan and Pakistan. In 2023 there were only 12 cases of WPV1 identified, compared to 22 in 2022, a decrease even with more extensive sewage screening in 2023. The bad news is that circulating vaccine-derived polio (cVDPV) cases, from live polio vaccine, continues to be a problem. The number of cases decreased (881 in 2022 to 524 in 2023) but the number of countries affected increased from 24 to 32. The vast majority of these are cVDPV1 and cVDPV2. WHO has newer and more effective vaccination strategies to eliminate both wild and vaccine-derived strain infections, but implementation is difficult.
Books - Red and Other Colors
Regular readers of this blog know that I'm an avid reader. I'm not an avid book collector, however. I try to keep a relatively static number of books in the house, requiring donating old books to my neighborhood public library's used bookstore as I acquire new ones (my last trip to a used bookstore resulted in 11 additions to my sagging bookshelves). However, I'm now reminded that I have 3 collections that I don't recycle from my shelves.
First is the Red Book. I own all editions dating back to 1961, the 13th edition, plus the 6th edition of 1944. I've been unable to find the remaining 11 editions, probably because I'm not as adept at used bookstore searches as I am at PubMed searches. I'll keep trying. Three pediatric infectious diseases giants, Drs. Larry Pickering, Georges Peter, and Stan Shulman, wrote a nice review of Red Book history in 2013.
My other 2 non-recyclable book collections are very different. One is the Audrey/Maturin series of nautical novels by Patrick O'Brian. I also own several of his lesser works. I'm not sure why I hang on to all of those; perhaps it's because my initial attempt at reading one was quickly abandoned due to boredom. Years later I picked it up again and was hooked. My other collector fascination is the Parker noir series by Richard Stark, a pseudonym of Donald Westlake. I lack many in the series which I could easily buy as newly issued printings, but I prefer to prowl used bookstores for older copies. I haven't happened upon an old one in years, but hope springs eternal.
Well, not really horror stories, but it was a slow week for epidemics that allowed me to finish two somewhat disturbing pieces of literature. First, the news.
I'm pleased to report nothing particularly new on the measles front, so I won't bother with the recitation of statistics and graphs. Based on the measles incubation period, it appears we are out of the woods from the Chicago clusters thanks to excellent public health interventions. The Florida school issue hasn't surfaced again though we are still lacking accurate descriptions of how it was managed - did un-immunized children isolate at home, were catch-up immunizations administered?
A Few Covid Updates
This past week the World Health Organization Technical Advisory Group on COVID-19 Vaccine Composition (TAG-CO-VAC if you're attracted to cumbersome acronyms) advised use of a monovalent JN.1 variant vaccine for the next iteration. Although the WHO TAG-CO-VAC doesn't make official recommendations for the US, none of these discussions occur in a vacuum and I expect the FDA VRBPAC to come to the same conclusion when they meet on the subject on May 16. The CDC/ACIP likely will rule on this in late June, in time for potential fall booster recommendations.
Here's the latest family tree in the US showing the.relationships of the currently circulating variants.
Also noteworthy is a change in hospital covid reporting. As of May 1, hospitals no longer are required to report covid hospitalizations. Although efforts are underway to go back to mandatory reporting, for now all hospital reporting is voluntary which will likely mean no reporting for many institutions. So, don't try to compare future covid hospitalization rates to prior data. It would be another apples and oranges comparison.
Lessons From Quality Improvement
This month's issue of Pediatrics contained some QI articles. They are worthwhile reading for the QI aspects, but I think many front-line pediatric healthcare providers might want to compare their own practices to the standards used in two of the studies concerning infectious diseases.
The first of the studies involved standards for management of well-appearing febrile infants ages 8 to 60 days in emergency departments. Parenthetically, I'm in awe of the authors for pulling off a multi-institutional research study in the midst of the pandemic. I barely had time to breath during some of those months.
The authors looked at multiple outcomes, and I won't go into the actual QI processes themselves. Here are the primary measures they sought to improve (remember these are all well-appearing infants):
90% of infants 29–60 d with normal inflammatory markers (and either a negative UA or a positive UA) DO NOT have CSF obtained
90% of infants 29–60 d with normal inflammatory markers and negative UA discharged from the ED
90% of infants 29–60 d with normal inflammatory markers and negative UA DO NOT receive antibiotics
90% of infants 8–60 d with negative cultures have appropriate discharge from the hospital within 36 h from the time blood cultures were received by the laboratory
How does your local ED or practice compare?
The second article also was hospital-focused and carried out during pandemic peaks. It dealt with minimizing unnecessary antibiotic use in common pediatric infections for children above 60 days of age. Again, many outcomes were examined, but think about these in your own practice:
Antibiotic duration for community-acquired pneumonia < 10 days
Antibiotic duration for UTI < 10 days
Antibiotic duration for skin and soft tissue infections < 5 days
The above durations for CAP and UTI probably are too long. It would be difficult to justify therapy beyond 7 days for these entities assuming good clinical response, and courses as short as 5 days have been suggested.
There's a lot more to these studies that I haven't mentioned. Please look at them if you manage these types of patients in your practice.
Of Cows and Cats
Bird flu, primarily influenza A H5N1, continues to surprise us. Let me state up front, however, there is no reason to be overly concerned about consumption of pasteurized dairy products or getting rid of your pet cat. People who ingest unpasteurized dairy or have close contact with cows or chickens (including those backyard coops) need to be cautious.
Genetic testing of dairy cow milk samples and of 2 cats who died at the dairy farm strongly suggests transmission of influenza A H5N1 from cows to cats. The cats had ingested unpasteurized milk at the farm. The cows were only mildly ill, but the cats had severe neurologic symptoms due to the virus. This report concerns only a few animals but at the least suggests that humans could be at risk for infection from unpasteurized dairy products.
We still have only one known human infection related to dairy cows in the US, but now we have more details about that case. As reported earlier, this dairy farm worker had mild symptoms consisting of pain and redness of the right eye. Especially given the perhaps mild and atypical presentation of influenza in this instance, more testing of asymptomatic dairy workers and other high risk individuals is needed.
I had mentioned in previous posts I'm trying to monitor USDA updates on this situation, but so far most have just clogged my inbox with irrelevant notices. I did receive one relevant alert that at least told me someone is watching out for us. Due to concerns about bird flu in the Chiba prefecture in Japan, imports of live birds as well as bird products and byproducts are prohibited. In case you are thinking about bringing back some bird souvenirs from Chiba, please be aware:
"Processed avian products and byproducts, including eggs and egg products, for personal use originating from or transiting a restricted prefecture and entering in passenger baggage must:
have a thoroughly cooked appearance; or
be shelf-stable as a result of APHIS-approved packaging and cooking (i.e., packaged in a hermetically sealed container and cooked by a commercial method after such packing to produce an article that is shelf stable without refrigeration); or
be accompanied by an APHIS import permit and/or government certification confirming that the products or byproducts were treated in accordance with APHIS requirements.
Unprocessed avian products and byproducts for personal use or in passenger baggage originating from or transiting a restricted prefecture will not be permitted to enter the United States. This includes hunter harvested, non-fully finished avian trophies and meat."
Reliable information on bird flu is increasing. It seems very likely that pasteurization effectively inactivates live H5N1 from dairy products and that these influenza strains remain susceptible to commonly available antiviral agents used for influenza. But, I still have questions:
What is the range of symptoms of avian flu infection in a wide range of animals, including humans?
How common is asymptomatic infection in various species?
What is the specificity and sensitivity of commonly-used influenza detection methods for influenza A H5N1?
For now, even though we are beyond our winter flu season, anyone with flu-like illness should be tested for influenza and also asked about exposure risks involving domestic or wild animals or ingestion of unpasteurized dairy products. Look to the CDC website for guidance.
My Disturbing Week
My wife abandoned reading Ian McEwan's latest novel, Lessons, due to its unsettling content in its early pages. Nonetheless, I decided to slog through this nearly 500-page tome and found I couldn't put it down. It was truly disturbing, including depictions of abuse of the young male protagonist that were hard to read. Ultimately, though, I found the novel very thought-provoking in spite of the fact that the protagonist wasn't very likable and seemed to respond passively to much of his life events. These events were shaped by a series of historical occurrences that also were meaningful to me: World War II (before my time, but still significant) the Cuban missile crisis in the 1960s, the fall of the Berlin wall, the September 11 attack, and more recently the January 6 attack, among others.
About a week ago I happened to watch Apocalypse Now Redux, the longer version of the 1979 movie about the Vietnam War which itself was a take on Joseph Conrad's Heart of Darkness. The longer movie version added more uncomfortable scenes to the already unsettling original. As a boy I had read at least 3 of Conrad's novels plus maybe a few short stories, but never Heart of Darkness. It's really a novella, just under 150 pages, and I felt compelled to read it this week. I loved it, as I do most of Contrad's works. More than that, I was astounded at how deftly the novella was transplanted from the late 19th century into late 1960s Vietnam. How did it not win the academy award for best adapted screenplay? (That was Kramer vs. Kramer.) I found myself waiting to see if the 19th century Kurtz would have the same *final utterance as in the movie version. You'll need to read the book to find out!
My Respite Week
Given the slow times in infectious diseases (now I've jinxed myself) and a busy week of other activities in front of me, I'm planning to skip a Sunday post for Mother's Day. Barring any major events, I'll see you next on May 19.
Well of course there is, that's why I try to sprinkle my weekly posts with comments on bird feeders, squirrels, novels I've been reading, and other escapades. This past week I happened upon a former colleague of mine who has taken this to new levels, much to my enjoyment.
We seem to be free of serious infectious diseases drama in the past week, unless you are a dairy cow.
Avian Flu
Initially only previewed in news reports and even now lacking details, one thing is clear: influenza A H5N1 infection in US dairy cows is much more widespread than previously revealed. We were surprised by this because asymptomatic infection is common and cow testing was only being performed in symptomatic animals. (This is reminiscent of the early days of covid!) The FDA and Department of Agriculture both report finding positive avian flu PCR tests in 1 out of 5 samples of pasteurized milk tested, although I can't find details about the total numbers and the geographic distribution of milk samples tested.
Of course, a positive PCR merely means that nucleic acid has been detected. It is highly likely that pasteurization inactivates H5N1 virus, and preliminary reports from FDA suggest this is true. Again, details are not available, but certainly no cause for panic about drinking pasteurized milk.
The take-home messages are clear: 1) H5N1 infection is highly prevalent in US dairy cow herds if 20% of all milk samples are PCR positive; 2) there is even more reason now to avoid ingestion of unpasteurized dairy products; and 3) USDA, FDA, and CDC are performing poorly in providing transparency and detailed evidence to the public. They say they are working on this, let's hope we see the fruits of that labor in the coming few weeks.
And, to give our federal agencies some credit, CDC has a spiffed-up web site for avian flu now, with weekly updates. Here's a quick view for the week ending April 20:
Note that this site deals only with human disease. If you want to get more on dairy cattle, you'll need to go to the USDA site. Here you can realize how geographically widespread the situation is.
USDA now has new guidelines for testing dairy cattle being transported interstate. Perhaps testing needs to be expanded beyond just interstate transport.
Covid Calm
Covid activity continues to fall, and weekly deaths now appear to be consistently less than 1000 even considering there is significant reporting delay for covid deaths. The vast majority are in the elderly.
Two new studies appeared highlighting covid vaccine side effects in children. One was a prospective cohort study utilizing insurance databases that likely carried some risk of classification errors because the authors did not perform any medical records review for verification. The study confirmed the known risks for myocarditis or pericarditis for ages 12 - 17 years with the Pfizer vaccine. Also, they found a possible safety signal for seizure occurring following both Pfizer and Moderna vaccination in 2 - 4 or 5 year-old children. This is pretty iffy; as they explained in the body of the text, it may simply be an artifact of how they defined the baseline seizure rate as a comparison number. This is worthy of further study, but in my opinion not something that should be put on the list of definite side effects yet.
The other study was a massive (3.9 million children) look at covid cases in California from 4/1/20 through 2/27/23, again using an administrative database. The article has too many explanatory graphs to show here, but the bottom line from the authors' predictive models suggests that vaccination prevented about 146,000 covid cases in 12 - 15 year-olds, 230,000 cases in 5 - 11 year-olds, and 168 hospitalizations in 6 - 59 month-olds. The authors did not find any association of vaccination with numbers of cases in the youngest age group, possibly because the numbers of vaccinated children were too small during the study period.
Our friends across the pond reported on various covid features from this past winter, November 2023 through March 2024. Results are based on self-reported data from a longitudinal survey study. Here are the main points:
An estimated 3.3% (2 million) of people living in private households in England and Scotland were experiencing self-reported long COVID (symptoms continuing for more than four weeks after a confirmed or suspected coronavirus (COVID-19) infection that were not explained by something else).
Long COVID symptoms adversely affected the day-to-day activities of 1.5 million people (74.7% of those with self-reported long COVID), with 381,000 (19.2% of those with self-reported long COVID) reporting that their ability to undertake their day-to-day activities had been "limited a lot".
Those in the youngest (aged 3 to 17 years) and oldest (65 years and over) age groups were the least likely to test positive for COVID-19 during the study period.
Those who have had a vaccination since September 2023 were less likely to test positive in the early waves of the study period (1 and 2); in later waves of the study period (3 and 4) there was no statistical difference.
Participants in the oldest and youngest age groups who did test positive in the study period were also less likely to report symptoms consistent with "influenza-like illness" compared with those in the middle age groups.
It's hard to find such recent data. I think this gives us a good peek at the future, assuming we don't have some major change in virus virulence or transmissibility.
Encouraging Progress in Malaria Prevention
I don't usually mention phase 2 trials because they are often much removed from clinical applicability and might change significantly once phase 3 trials are completed. This study is cause for optimism, so I'll break my custom here. Investigators in Mali performed the trial, part of which looked at 225 children randomized in equal numbers to a long-acting monoclonal antibody against Plasmodium falciparum with low dose, high dose, and placebo groups. Infection and clinical malaria was much less in the treatment groups.
The antibody is administered subcutaneously, a plus in resource-poor environments. If further studies confirm efficacy, this could save many lives.
Measles
No new cases were reported in the past week, good news though we know there will be more eventually. Also, I've been looking for more reliable assessments of worldwide activity and found another resource for Europe, the European Centre for Disease Control and Prevention. Updates appear only monthly. Here's what the most recent report, February, looked like:
Romania is the major hot spot, but note that many popular tourist destinations are represented. Here are current CDC recommendations that apply for all international travel:
Fiddlin' Will
By a happy occurrence in my web wanderings, I discovered a former colleague of mine was performing with his band, the Goldbug Revival, at a Salvadoran restaurant near my home. I crossed paths briefly with Will Sears when he was an infectious diseases fellow at NIH; he is now a medical officer at NIAID. However, in his "spare time," he is an accomplished musician. I was thrilled to see him on the fiddle and his wife Sarah singing lead at the band's first live performance and Sarah's first performance in front of a microphone ever. They were excellent!
See you next week. I'll be listening to some John Prine music in the meantime, waiting for Goldbug Revival's first album to drop. Prine was an early covid victim, dying in April 2020.
I finished a wonderful novel last week; among other things, it reminded me of the beauty, complexity, and destructive forces in nature, certainly applicable to infections, pathogens, and vectors of disease.
The past week saw more publications than I could cover in depth (or that readers could tolerate, probably), so I had to narrow things down even more than I usually do. If you're feeling particularly adventuresome, some of the topics I excluded pertain to a new phase I Chlamydia vaccine trial that could prove to be a breakthrough eventually, more advice on use of the new pentavalent meningococcal vaccine, an in vitrostudy suggesting nasal epithelial properties account for less severe covid disease in children, and a tularemia outbreak in Utah beavers. I also left out the growing Salmonella outbreak linked to organic basil, though I did alert one of my sons who often shops at a store featuring the tainted product. Here's what made the cut this week.
Respiratory Disease Transmission is Not Binary
Most things in biology and medicine aren't binary, even if we tend to reduce our thinking to that level to simplify things. For example, most lab tests aren't just positive or negative, even though they are reported that way. The cutoff between those two choices are made to maximize specificity and sensitivity of the tests, but they don't necessarily work for all circumstances.
The World Health Organization provided an important new proposal for changing our longstanding terminology for spread of respiratory infections as either droplet or aerosol (airborne). It's just not that simple, as SARS-CoV-2 painfully taught us. I found I couldn't improve on WHO's explanation of the complexity of pathogen transmission through the air, so here it is verbatim with some highlights in red that are mine:
The following descriptors and stages have been defined by this extensively discussed consultation to characterize the transmission of pathogens through the air (under typical circumstances):
Individuals infected with a pathogen, during the infectious stage of the disease (the source), can generate particles containing the pathogen, along with water and respiratory secretions. Such particles are herein described as potentially ‘infectious particles’.
These potentially infectious particles are carried by expired airflow, exit the infectious person’s mouth/nose through breathing, talking, singing, spitting, coughing or sneezing and enter the surrounding air. From this point, these particles are known as ‘infectious respiratory particles’ or IRPs.
IRPs exist in a wide range of sizes (from sub-microns to millimetres in diameter). The emitted IRPs are exhaled as a puff cloud (travelling first independently from air currents and then dispersed and diluted further by background air movement in the room).
IRPs exist on a continuous spectrum of sizes, and no single cut off points should be applied to distinguish smaller from larger particles, this allows to move away from the dichotomy of previous terms known as ‘aerosols’ (generally smaller particles) and ‘droplets’ (generally larger particles).
Many environmental factors influence the way IRPs travel through air, such as ambient air temperature, velocity, humidity, sunlight (ultraviolet radiation), airflow distribution within a space, and many other factors, and whether they retain viability and infectivity upon reaching other individuals.
WHO still proposes a somewhat binary system of IRP spread, with "airborne transmission/inhalation" denoting pathogens which can spread at both short and longer distances, depending on various factors, versus "direct deposition," e.g. someone sneezes on you. It still may be confusing, but this is an important attempt to get past somewhat misleading advice such as a establishing a standard 6-foot distance between persons waiting in line.
Children and Adolescents Likely Still Benefit From Covid Vaccination
CDC has an update on covid vaccine effectiveness and durability, looking at the original monovalent vaccines over the time period from mid-December 2021 to late October 2023. Two doses of vaccine were 52% (95% CI 33%-66%) effective against hospitalization in the 5 - 18 year-old age group if vaccines were received no more than 4 months prior to hospitalization. From 4 to 12 months, protection against hospitalization waned significantly to 19% (95% CI 2%-32%). The report doesn't mention children less than 5 years of age, I suspect because vaccine authorization occurred later, numbers vaccinated are too small, and hospitalization was too uncommon to give reliable numbers.
Vaccine Adverse Events: New Numbers and a Terrific Interactive Web Site
The National Academies of Science, Engineering, and Medicine published new reports on adverse events from covid vaccines as well as an assessment of shoulder injuries from all vaccine administrations. The reports are excellent, but I fell in love with their web site. The NASEM group used levels of evidence to summarize current knowledge about various vaccine adverse events. The categories are evidence that a) establishes a causal relationship; b) favors acceptance of a causal relationship; c) inadequate to accept or reject a causal relationship; or d) favors rejection of a causal relationship. (Certainly this is far from a binary categorization!)
For covid vaccination they looked at six categories of adverse events: cardiac and vascular, female infertility, hearing conditions, immune-mediated events, neurologic events, and sudden deaths. The interactive web site allows you to pick and choose among various topics and subtopics and vaccines. Here's what the portion on myocarditis looks like:
You can also access the pdf version of the report (note it is a pre-publication proof, could contain some typos) to look at the summary and/or more details.
A Significant Change for Syphilis Screening From ACOG
I'm thrilled to see new recommendations for syphilis screening of pregnant people from the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists. I feel like my practice is a congenital syphilis quagmire right now. This updated recommendation gets away from the risk-based approach for screening which has always been a bit vague and clearly less useful with the resurgence of syphilis in the US. Now, every pregnant person should have syphilis testing 3 times: at the first prenatal visit, during the third trimester, and at birth. Previously a pregnant person with good prenatal care could escape with being screened only once early in pregnancy, a practice that would miss recent infection or infection acquired later in pregnancy. They also remind us that 40% of congenital syphilis occurs in infants whose mothers did not receive prenatal care; syphilis screening should be considered for pregnant people at every interaction with the healthcare system, such as emergency or urgent care visits.
Fake News From USDA?
Because of the avian flu concerns in the US, I've been trying for the first time to use alerts from the US Department of Agriculture on the status of avian influenza in wildlife and domesticated animals, including the recent importance of dairy animals. So far the alerts aren't telling me much, just clogging my in box with unhelpful information. So, I was a bit dismayed to see a recent NY Times article criticizing USDA transparency. Unfortunately the article requires a subscription, but it mentions an "obscure" USDA update (that I didn't receive) mentioning influenza A H5N1 further spreading among dairy cow herds and from there to poultry. More distressing to me is a claim in the Times article stating that asymptomatic infections have been discovered in a herd, but not yet reported by USDA; this is important since screening advice for dairy farmers currently is focused on symptoms in the cattle, with no screening of healthy-appearing cows. Perhaps USDA hasn't reported this asymptomatic infection possibility because it hasn't been verified, but one hopes they will be more transparent (and provide better updates) than they have so far. CDC learned a lot about public communication and transparency during the covid pandemic that should inform communications from USDA and other government agencies that we depend on.
Measles
Only 4 new cases reported in the last week, hoping we stay in this lull for a good while.
Elm Beetle Romance
That novel I finished recently was Daniel Mason's North Woods; it's had mixed reviews but I thoroughly enjoyed it. The author happens to be a psychiatrist, and this recent offering from him is an entertaining look at the happenings in a house in rural Massachusetts over several centuries. I had a great chuckle from a brief description of Dutch elm disease complete with a steamy sex scene involving elm bark beetles. Maybe I need to get out more.
