Regular blog readers know I've taken a few months respite from posting to get my newly retired status figured out (still working on that) and deciding whether to continue blogging (affirmative, as indicated by this posting).
Even before the COVID-19 pandemic I was struck by how poorly we healthcare providers communicate risks, benefits, and management choices to each other and to our patients. We haven't done a good job of communicating the uncertainties inherent in medical science and practice; for multiple reasons, the pandemic has transformed this communication gap into a wide chasm. I'll be trying harder to be an effective communicator, not only to pediatric healthcare providers as before but also to patients, families, and the public in general.
The title of this post comes from the 1967 movie "Cool Hand Luke" starring Paul Newman and depicting the lives of jailers and inmates in the Deep South shortly after World War II. Having never watched the movie in its entirety before, I forced myself to do so recently. More on that later.
Bivalent COVID-19 Vaccines for 5-year-olds and Up
I hope all pediatric healthcare providers are now well aware that both Pfizer-BioNTech (ages 5 and up) and Moderna (ages 6 and up) bivalent vaccines are authorized for booster doses. Note that the bivalent part of the terminology just means it contains proteins from both the original strain of the SARS-CoV-2 virus that appeared in late 2019 as well that from the more recent omicron variants BA.4 and BA.5 that have some ability to evade the immune protection of the original vaccine.
Although we don't yet have peer-reviewed publications of the data leading to this authorization, know that it was based primarily on safety and antibody data, rather than a prolonged trial looking at how effective the boosters are in preventing severe COVID-19 disease in children - that information will take many more months to accumulate, and studies are ongoing as are studies in younger children.
At this point in the pandemic, the scientific data on the benefits of vaccination are clear. Compared to outcomes of natural infection with the SARS-CoV-2 virus, vaccines come out ahead for all age groups and risk factors, including for children. Of course, the magnitude of the benefit (bang for the buck) is greater for older individuals and those with underlying conditions leaving them at higher risk for COVID-19 complications. Risk for a poor outcome in a healthy child with COVID-19 disease is much lower than in an old geezer like me, for example. Still, it's a slam dunk from my perspective: every child eligible for vaccination should receive the primary series and available boosters. Reliable information is available from the CDC website. Vaccine Recipient Information also is available. 'Nuff said.
Variations on a Theme
Regardless of what COVID-19 variants are up to, we are in for a tough winter of respiratory virus illness, including for children. Our usual seasonal patterns have changed since the pandemic started, but maybe this season will be more normalized. We have already had a very busy enteroviral illness season; this virus usually peaks in August/September and came back with a vengeance recently. Influenza is ramping up mostly in the southern US but will soon involve the entire country, and respiratory syncytial virus (RSV) activity is already up - usually RSV is a late fall/winter virus. In the days before the pandemic every winter I (selfishly) hoped that RSV season would taper off before flu season started; if they came at the same time, we'd all be working overtime. Now, we're layering COVID-19 on top of all this. I strongly recommend annual influenza vaccine for everyone who is eligible.
Everything so far is pointing to an increase in COVID-19 cases this winter season. For example, cases in the United Kingdom and elsewhere in Europe are already rising, and with so many unvaccinated children out there all going back to school, we can expect a lot of SARS-CoV-2 transmission. How much, and how severe, are unanswered questions so far. In part this depends on the behavior of the so-called virus variants.
The graph at the right depicts the most recent CDC data for circulating variants of SARS-CoV-2, as of October 15, 2022. First, the good news. These are all subvariants of the omicron variant; this has been the case for several months (remember the delta variant?). Omicron seems to be a variant that causes less severe illness in general.
Now for the bad news. Some of these subvariants show early indications that they are resistant to some of the therapies now very helpful in managing or preventing infections. Secondly, some of those now increasing, like the dark blue BA.4.6, may not be prevented by the original COVID-19 vaccines. That's why there was a big push to produce the bivalent vaccines that include components that could be more effective for these newer subvariants. Again, everyone eligible for the bivalent COVID-19 booster should receive it.
The real concern is that we are waiting for the next major change in the virus that could portend something that could evade our existing treatments and vaccines and cause more severe disease. As long as we have humans being infected, this virus will continue to mutate; the more infections, the more mutations and the more likely we'll see a worse version of the virus come to the forefront.
But enough of this doom and gloom! Sometime, maybe about a year ago when it became clear that SARS-CoV-2 had incredible ability to produce new variants, I was reminded of the Goldberg Variations, a set of keyboard pieces written by J. S. Bach. Johann Gottlieb Goldberg studied under Bach and likely was the first person to perform Bach's variations. My favorite pianist playing these variations (not that I've sampled all the recordings) is Glenn Gould. It is my never-fail stress reliever, especially needed during pandemic times.
Cool Hand Luke
Retirement has given me more freedom to go down rabbit holes, and when I found out the "failure to communicate" quote came from this movie (though not present in the book from which it was adapted) I had to watch the full movie. I said at the start of this post that I had to force myself to watch the entire movie; the emotional and physical brutality depicted was a bit tough for me. However, I enjoyed performances of all the lead actors plus a few "hey, doesn't he look like ..." moments that I discovered were younger versions of future stars, their names buried in a long list of cast credits.
The quote itself, delivered by the great character actor Strother Martin in his role as prison warden, is: "What we've got here is failure to communicate." (It is #11 on the American Film Institute's list of 100 greatest American movie quotes.)